1950’s Bob special project

BloomR

New Member
Hi folks. I am new to the forum although I have been browsing It for a couple or years in anticipation of getting going on some restoration projects. I have a couple of 1950’s era Chestnut and Peterborough 15 footers recently acquired and I hope to get going on them this summer. These will be my first restoration projects and I am hoping to get advice from folks here along the way.

I came across what I think is a Chestnut Bob’s special produced between 1950 to 1956. The canoe was being sold by the nephew of the original owner who bought it in Ottawa in the 50’s. Mostly stored indoors and seemed in decent shape. But there were signs that it had been recanvassed or at least repainted. The paint is now badly cracked and peeled. I first looked at the canoe 10 months ago and have read just about every post I can find on this forum to try to answer some questions resulting from the inspection. New canvas and hull inspection later this summer. In meantime there are some novel quirks in the construction of this canoe that might be appreciated by vintage canoe sleuths so here is the story:

-the boat is a Bob’s special based on my read of related threads here in the Forum (ghost image of original Chestnut deck decal, ribs (1/4” thickness), weight (<60 lbs), keel (beveled), caned seats etc.)
-there is a plate tacked to the upper side of the stern deck that provides a clue regarding age. The tag reads “Supplied by Blair Equipment Co. Ottawa, Canada”. I looked up the company and found records of it in Ottawa newspaper ads offering hardware sales and boat repair service in the early 1950’s until it apparently closed shop in 1956. I concluded that the shop was a retailer of Chestnut canoes and this was the point of origin. And since that period is reputed to be a time of good quality work at Chesnut, I bought the canoe last week.

- now that its home I noted the patina and styling of the interior has an “old“ feel to it. I have seen a lot of wooden boats from the 30s to 50’s (my father has refinished Muskoka boats for many years and having those wood boats around sort of gets into your DNA). I got wondering if maybe the boat was older and simply refinished by Blair Equipment and sold used with theit tag attached at that time.

Some things that make me wonder about that:

-all the outwale screws are Phillips! As are all the keel screws. Yet I found that some of the stem band screws were slot except for those above the waterline. Not a Robertson screw anywhere.

-keel screws in every rib which I believe I read is an older trait?

-the decks are nicely arched with the characteristic bevel underneath. They are heart shaped but for Bobs that seems to have very little correlation with age.

-the stem is original and doesn’t appear to be tapered

So after all that, my question is whether anyone has come across a vintage boat like this with so many Philips fasteners when it is almost certain to have no history in the US. Where Phillips would have been common.

If folks agree that the above all adds up to a 1950’s era build, maybe the serial number stamp is of interest to folks looking for a number with an estimated age (1950 to 1956). Serial number is “9218 15 EX”. Also odd to me that the serial number stamp is at the stern not the bow. Or is that typical.

Thanks for reading if you made it this far. I am sure to have questions about how to bring this pretty little canoe back into paddling condition.
 

Attachments

  • BB656375-5201-4AF8-8904-7C8AB8E32D46.jpeg
    BB656375-5201-4AF8-8904-7C8AB8E32D46.jpeg
    272 KB · Views: 129
  • 641353F4-16B5-47A8-B06A-9F33A0D49865.jpeg
    641353F4-16B5-47A8-B06A-9F33A0D49865.jpeg
    229.6 KB · Views: 128
  • 0A6E28D0-38F0-4518-B5A0-C6F09D67046F.jpeg
    0A6E28D0-38F0-4518-B5A0-C6F09D67046F.jpeg
    323 KB · Views: 128
  • F15D509C-F0E2-4E03-B545-28ADBB071510.jpeg
    F15D509C-F0E2-4E03-B545-28ADBB071510.jpeg
    267.3 KB · Views: 120
  • 360EF06C-5462-499E-90A7-58E2A47EE594.jpeg
    360EF06C-5462-499E-90A7-58E2A47EE594.jpeg
    312.8 KB · Views: 124
  • A04AEF14-1A1E-425D-91EA-0F02FDD176A9.jpeg
    A04AEF14-1A1E-425D-91EA-0F02FDD176A9.jpeg
    175.8 KB · Views: 133
  • 123E5346-C9B9-4EE4-8BD2-EBAA46C54D6C.jpeg
    123E5346-C9B9-4EE4-8BD2-EBAA46C54D6C.jpeg
    259 KB · Views: 126
  • EBF50A2F-871C-41A6-9DC2-A8CB766C5E0F.jpeg
    EBF50A2F-871C-41A6-9DC2-A8CB766C5E0F.jpeg
    166.9 KB · Views: 122
  • DD58B757-BA3E-4AB4-AD83-5F36CCFD1D72.jpeg
    DD58B757-BA3E-4AB4-AD83-5F36CCFD1D72.jpeg
    248.7 KB · Views: 120
Last edited:
Nice project. I have a similar Chestnut project in progress as well as a completed restoration of a Chestnut Chum.

I'm curious to know the depth of your canoe... from top of rib at widest beam to a straight edge laid gunnel to gunnel. Bob Special should be 12" (or so, allowing for movement due to age and storage).

Post lots of pictures along the way. There are Chestnut fans here...

Project Chestnut canoe:
tempImage8PjXCv.png


Completed Chum:
tempImageKOV6Q4.png
 
Thanks for the inspiration Patrick. Amazing work on the Chum.

I measured the depth from top of rib to gunwale height at the thwart when I first came across the boat and it was ~12”. Beam was 36”. So those dimensions helped me narrow down the options. Boat is now in storage.

What to folks do for gunwale and keel fasteners these days? Since the phillips screws aren’t original, would brass Robertson be a reasonable and accurate choice? hanger bolts seem ok but everything Philips needs to go.
 
Welcome to the forums. I also did some research on "Blair Equipment Ltd" in Ottawa after coming across an identical plate on another hull. This one was attached over the decal on the bow deck of an Ogilvy V stern.

02 - 50s square stern Blair Equipment.jpg


Found that "Blair Equipment Ltd" was still advertising as late as 1959. Here's their simple ad from a local Ottawa area college yearbook...
Blair Equipment Ltd - 1959 Best Years.JPG

Source link: https://archive.org/details/stpatricksbestyears1959/page/150/mode/2up?q="Blair+Equipment+Ltd"

Also, they were mentioned in the Canadian Government publication - The Public Accounts of Canada (1959) by the Department of Finance mentions the company receiving $10, 764 as payment for a public works contract. So it seems they might have still been around for a few years after 1956.

Your faded ghost outline on the deck is also consistent with this era as most decals in later periods were not die-cut precisely around the complex leaf pattern but had a discernible border as seen in this late 60's Prospector.

Late 60s Prospector.jpg


These left behind a bulkier looking ghost outlines like this one on a similar era Playmate...
Mid to Late 60s Playmate - decal outline perimeter.jpg
 
I very much appreciate the additional details and corrections on the info about Blair Equipment Co. And the photos.

The photo of your Ogilvy deck caught my eye because the ends of the cant ribs look narrow all the way to the stem. After reading that this is a feature of older Chestnuts, I am wondering if that canoe is an older boat (pre-fire) or are the cant ribs not a trait useful for aging Ogilvy models?

it’s just interesting to me because it looks at first glance you Ogilvy photo makes me think an older rib arrangement that I thought would typically predate the 50’s era tag.
 
I would suspect the Phillips screws are replacements.
Screws used should be silicon bronze. Brass is not strong enough.
See the "Fasteners" tutorial for explanation in the "Skills 101; Fastenings for Small Boats" in the current issue (July/August 2023) of Wooden Boat magazine.

I have restored a few Chestnuts as well, Interestingly, two 14'9" boats found separately appeared to be twins (one red, one green, now turquoise), but, when measured, one was one inch wider and one inch deeper.
 

Attachments

  • red canoe quarter view.jpg
    red canoe quarter view.jpg
    288.2 KB · Views: 95
  • Em and Charlotte in Turq.JPG
    Em and Charlotte in Turq.JPG
    213.8 KB · Views: 97
Thank you Rob. I will be sure to get a copy of the current WB issue. Timely as renewal is coming up for Father’s Day. Seems I’m getting to the age where gifts for my dad are as relevant to me as to him.

the photos are great. Good inspiration for what this boat can look like when done up right.
 
I very much appreciate the additional details and corrections on the info about Blair Equipment Co. And the photos.

The photo of your Ogilvy deck caught my eye because the ends of the cant ribs look narrow all the way to the stem. After reading that this is a feature of older Chestnuts, I am wondering if that canoe is an older boat (pre-fire) or are the cant ribs not a trait useful for aging Ogilvy models?

it’s just interesting to me because it looks at first glance you Ogilvy photo makes me think an older rib arrangement that I thought would typically predate the 50’s era tag.

I've been informed by the knowledgeable folks here that cant ribs alone shouldn't be used an accurate indicator of age or a pre-fire build. Ogilvy's were built a bit different too since they already had very wide 3" ribs.

Plus, the Ogilvy line was introduced in 1932 according to the write-up in the 1934 catalogue where only one model (18ft DAVE) appears. In the 1950 catalogue, the line includes 16ft up to 26ft models. The V-sterns (Parr, Grilse, Pool, Trout, Salar) don't appear until the mid-50s. These would have been "new" models for Blair Equipment to showcase at the time.
 
Murat makes a good point, attached is a prefire open gunwhale 16’ showing the typical canadian wide forward cant, though about 3/4-1” narrower. Prefire closed rail canoes usually show a regular rib thinned to half thickness for a forward cant rib
 

Attachments

  • IMG_7166.jpeg
    IMG_7166.jpeg
    248.8 KB · Views: 118
  • IMG_7164.jpeg
    IMG_7164.jpeg
    131.1 KB · Views: 121
On my pre fire Teddy, the cant rip is wider than the others and is not fastened to the inwale.
PXL_20230301_155300300.jpg
 
Back
Top